GIVE US BACK HIS CAMERA!! (with constant news updates)
GIVE US BACK HIS CAMERA!! (with constant news updates)

Image by nofrills
Now I’m so angry. DON’T LET THEM BURY THE TRUTH.
Collage. The Reuters photo on the newspaper and today’s Mainich Shinbun web article.
As I wrote a couple of hours ago, Mr Yamaji from the APF News arrived in Rangoon last night and identified the body at the morgue. The Daily Yomiuri reports that he "silently looked at Nagai’s body for 10 minutes and seemed to be trying to suppress his sorrow over Nagai’s death."
Reading the Mainich Shinbun article (pictured above: in Japanese) is heart breaking.
QUOTE:
????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????……??????????????????????????????????????……
??????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????……????????????????????????????……9?30?1?31?
Rough translation in English:
Yamaji of the APF News phoned his office in Tokyo, right after he identified the body. His co-worker told Yamaji said in a shaky voice that Nagai’s right hand was rigid in a shape just as if he was holding a camera.
Yamaji just lost the sense of time, just staring at Nagai’s face, which was more calm and peaceful than he had expected. On the forehead he had a graze, which he must have got when he was knocked down to the ground. Yamaji issued a statement that he "knew that Nagai was dead even though I couldn’t believe it until I saw the body. I want to know the truth. I demand to know how and why he was shot. I want doctors in Japan to examine the body, too."
Yamaji is going to get Nagai’s personal belongings and tapes he filmed at the Japanese Embassy on the morning of Sunday 30th September. (The Mainichi Shinbun, 13:31 JST, 30 September 2007)
Well, basically this is what the article says.
Then, we’ve got another news in the evening: At the Japanese Embassy in Burma, Yamaji couldn’t find the camera Nagai was holding at his death. Another camera was found, but that camera was missing.
That is, the camera has been taken away by somebody. Who took it away? If he or she took the camera for money, give the videotape back to Mr Yamaji or to the Japanese Embassy. If the Burmese police or military took it away, just give it back. The truth is already known all over the world.
Burmese junta murdered this guy. And is it not enough? They are going to kill his soul by taking away what he had been filming on that day for us to see.
Don’t deprive me and other Japanese people of the last report by this respected Japanese journalist. Please.


del.icio.us
Digg
26 Comments
UPDATE@30 September 2007:
If you read Japanese:
headlines.yahoo.co.jp/hl?a=20070930-00000079-jij-soci
Quote:
In English for the gist of it:
It is very likely that the police took the camera away and has not given it back. Mr Yamaji of the APF News demands it be returned.
UPDATE@1 October 2007:
If you read Japanese:
?????
headlines.yahoo.co.jp/hl?a=20071001-00000028-maip-int
?????
headlines.yahoo.co.jp/hl?a=20071001-00000909-san-pol
In English for the gist of the articles:
- Yamaji, a colleague of the slain journalist Nagai, did not find the camera Nagai was holding at death among his belongings that were returned from the police.
- Yamaji did get Nagai’s belongings returned from the police: his passport, his mobile phone, his notebook and a Canon with a videotape in it.
- The "last moment" camera was a Sony, while the only camera Yamaji could find among his belongings was a Canon.
- The Canon camera was a back-up. The videotape inside the Canon camera had nothing noteworthy: only test-shots inside a hotel room.
- The Burmese police claim all the belongings to Nagai have been returned.
- Nagai’s mother, 75, is heartbroken. She suggests it might be something the junta does not want the world to know that her son was filming. She wants his son’s body to be back as soon as possible. "How many days have passed since he was killed? This is unbearable," she told the reporters.
Meanwhile:
- Mr Machimura, the chief cabinet secretary of Japan, said at a press conference on 1st Oct, that the Japanese government would ask the Burmese junta government to make sure if it was true that all the belongings had been returned.
- Mr Yabunaka, who is visiting Burma, will urge them to return all of Nagai’s belongings.
- Machimura also said the Japanese government will be asking about the humanitarian situation in Burma. (This translation is too rough!)
- According to Machimura, the Burmese doctor(s) who performed a post mortem claims it is unlikely he was shot at a point-blank range. "On the body, there were no burns that he should have got when shot at a 20-centimeter distance, and there were no gun powders that he’d have got when shot at a one-meter range."
- Machimura questions this, and said another post mortem in Japan will be needed to see the truth.
Well, I can only hope that they don’t claim it’s "politically motivated" for Japan to conduct an inquest.
I feel really sorry for his mom, who’s been waiting for four days since her son’s death. (In Japan, a dead person’s body is usually cremated in two or three days.)
The TimesNowTV of India reports:
http://www.timesnow.tv/NewsDtls.aspx?NewsID=3108
News clip in English (Reuters):
Japan demands Burma return journalist’s camera
http://www.guardian.co.uk/news/video/2007/oct/01/japan.statement
The clip is in Japanese, with English subtitles. It shows another footage at the scene (it’s a new footage), seemingly seconds after the shooting. A soldier pulls fallen Nagai by the right hand. The Sony camera had already dropped from his hand, although it looks like he was still not dead. Then several soldiers carried his body away.
Then the clip shows Mr Machimura, the chief cabinet secretary of Japan, speaking at a daily press conference about the missing camera.
Still photos from the "new" footage:
http://www.repubblica.it/2006/05/gallerie/esteri/inedite-birmani...
# From number 4 to number 7. The smoke in the number 7 is tear gas, as far as I’ve heard.
Accorging to the Guardian blog, which quotes one Burmese blog (http://soneseayar.blogspot.com/), "Major General Hla Htay Win of the Rangoon Division has been sacked amid speculation that he is being blamed for the killing of" Kenji Nagai.
blogs.guardian.co.uk/news/2007/10/burma_crisis_monday.html
UPDATE@7:00 am, 2 October 2007:
Mr Yabunaka, a senior official of the Japanese Foreign Ministry, has met several people from the junta. He officially demanded Nagai’s Sony camera be returned and told Japan wants to know what exactly happened.
No mention to the Major General Hla Htay Win (see my comment above) in a Japanese TV news (at the NNN, to whom Nagai did his last telephone report).
?????
headlines.yahoo.co.jp/hl?a=20071002-00000002-jij-int
Among the people Yabunaka met was Maun Min, a deputy foreign minister. Maun Win told Yabunaka that Nagai had entered on a tourist visa, and that the shooting was an accident that occurred in the mess. But he said he understood how his family felt over the camera that the slain journalist was holding at his last moments, and that he would get in touch with the people in the know.
?????
headlines.yahoo.co.jp/hl?a=20071001-00000215-yom-int
Also in the news… Mr Yamaji of the APF News will visit the place where his colleague was shot and offer some flowers. It was reported the police did not allow him to visit the place, but it now seems the authority changed their mind.
UPDATE@7:30 am, 2 October 2007:
Japan is going to stop some of its aid to Burma.
After the Burmese military crackdown on the protesters, the Japanese government have decided to cut its aid to Burma, such as grant aid and technical aid. Japan will review the current plans and projects, and decide which ones would be stopped or suspended. There will be no new humanitarian-aid project.
?????
headlines.yahoo.co.jp/hl?a=20071002-00000301-yom-pol
UPDATE@3 October 2007:
Reuters article:
Japan to cut back on aid to Myanmar – paper
Tue Oct 2, 2007 1:27am EDT
http://www.reuters.com/article/homepageCrisis/idUSSP320349._CH_….
I forgot to post this here:
Ko htike has published the death list, quoting AAPP. The list has six names:
UPDATE@7:00 am, 3 October 2007:
Mr Yamaji of the APF News visited the site where his colleague was shot. An Agence France-Presse article posted on the Sydney Morning Herald has a picture.
http://www.smh.com.au/news/world/monks-from-rebel-age-group-a-ra...
Mr Yamaji is accompanied by another Japanese man, possibly an official at the Embassy – the man with a paper bag. Mr Yamaji himself has a camera. They pay tribute to the fallen journalist with white flowers (chrysanthemum) and incense. (Japanese Buddhists pay tribute to the dead with incense sticks rather than candles. And white chrysanthemum is always used at funerals and memorials.)
Nagai’s body will leave Bankok tonight for Tokyo. The Japanese police expects to conduct a post mortem when the body arrives on the morning of 4th October.
News articles in Japanese:
headlines.yahoo.co.jp/hl?a=20071003-00000002-jij-int
headlines.yahoo.co.jp/hl?a=20071002-00000212-jij-int
Mr Yamaji was at first denied a tribute visit to the site by the Burmese officials. But after the Japanese foreign ministry demanded, he was allowed to pay a visit as he had expected.
Before visiting the site, Mr Yamaji visited the hotel Mr Nagai was staying. The room had flowers for Nagai, and the hotel manager said to Yamaji, "I feel terribly sorry. I would like to extend my deepest condolences to Nagai’s family."
Arriving at the site, Mr Yamaji put down the flower basket and observed a silent prayer, then he said "I’m so sorry it took so long for me to come here." It’s been five days since he was shot to death. On the spot where he fell, there were bloodstains.
UPDATE@noon, 3 October 2007:
The AFP reports about the Japanese government’s question about the Burmese official’s claims that the shooting was an accident.
http://www.thepeninsulaqatar.com/Display_news.asp?section=World_...
Mituso Sakaba is ???? in Japanese. This story is not yet reported in the Japanese media. (I searched for his name but couldn’t find any articles.)
In Japanese (????):
?????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????
UPDATE@13:00, 4th October 2007:
It’s been a week since Kenji Nagai was shot dead. In the Buddhism in Japan, the seventh day (including the day the person died, so it was yesterday in fact) is a very important day when friends and family pray for the peace of his/her soul. ??.
Nagai’s body was flown back to Tokyo this morning, probably around 06:00 am, acconpanied by the APF News president Mr Toru Yamaji. Yamaji brought Nagai’s belongings, including a blood-stained notebook he had in his bag. But there was not the Sony mini-videocam.
Here’s an Agence France Presse news article:
Japanese journalist’s body returns from Myanmar
afp.google.com/article/ALeqM5jKYXB0AoKmB4LiUYlyUuYhy2TAiQ
In Japanese:
?????
headlines.yahoo.co.jp/hl?a=20071004-00000901-san-soci
?????
headlines.yahoo.co.jp/hl?a=20071004-00000003-yom-soci
His coffin was covered with a red sheet, which I think is a tribute to the Burmese people because in Japan red is an unusual colour for a death.
The Yomiuri article above reports that Nagai’s parents met their son at a hospital in Tokyo. They had flown to Tokyo from Ehime on 3rd October.
Some additional notes@4th October 2007:
The APF News (NOT affiliated with the AFP, a French news agency) is a small independent news production company based in Tokyo. They play a vital part of Japanese news reporting – Japanese MSM usually don’t send their own reporters to the war/conflict zones but send independent journalists. Kenji Nagai was one of such journalists.
Mr Toru Yamaji, the head of the APF News, is also a journalist. He visited Burma a number of times (in 1989, 1990, 1995 …), and that was where the APF News started.
You can watch a clip by Yamaji at their site:
http://www.apfnews.com/
It’s Japanese only, but find the ?????? (sitemap) button on the top left. Then scroll down the page to ????? (archive) right above the "BOOK & VIDEO’. In the ????? list, there are six news clips, and Yamaji’s Burma report (broadcast in 1995) is the second one: ????????????.
The clips are:
- ???????????: The Amiriyah Shelter, Baghdad, Iraq (1991)
- ??????????: All Burma Students’ Democratic Front (ABSDF), the Thai-Burma border area (1995)
- ??????????????: Bosnian Civil War – the Truth about the Ethnic Conflict (1993-1995)
- ?????????????????????????????: Somalia Civil War: Killing in the Name of Justice – the real face of the UN Peace-Enforcement Units (1993)
- ???????????????????????????: Child Soldiers: Get Them Back From The War Zone! – In The Case Of Sierra Leone (1996)
- ????????: Thailand’s AIDS Orphans (2000)
The last clip (Thailand’s AIDS Orphans) is a piece of work by Nagai. You can watch the clip at:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LPjWF6PtHrI
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=E1w0VG7UPn0
This is the orphan home in Thailand, set up by a Japanese humanitarian activist:
http://www.banromsai.jp/
# In English: http://www.banromsai.jp/info_e.html
UPDATE@15:00, 4th October 2007:
The BBC:
Reporter’s body returned to Japan
Last Updated: Thursday, 4 October 2007, 04:10 GMT 05:10 UK
news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/asia-pacific/7027237.stm
Meanwhile, it’s reported that Japan’s suspention will not play a major role as a pressure to the junta. According to this report (in Japanese), JETRO (the Japan External Trade Organization, a government-related organisation) has issued a report re: economies in Myanmar. The chief analyst sees 1) the recent price-rise is the problem, and it shows the fundamental and systematical problems of the Burmese economy, 2) the junta can make a lot of money by selling Burma’s natural gas when the price of oil is so high, 3) Japan has reduced its ties with the junta since 2003, so if Japan’s aid is cut back, only a limited effect is expected.
# The article is from Sankei media group, which is blantantly anti-China: i.e., they write only about China. But in fact, India’s role can’t be neglected as well as other ASEAN countries’ roles. And the fact is Japan has long supported the military government.
The Reuters and others reported that some of the detained monks and nuns were freed along with some of the local journalists, including the Tokyo Shinmun correspondent.
80 monks, 149 women, probably nuns, and 5 journalists were released.
In Japanese:
headlines.yahoo.co.jp/hl?a=20071004-00000909-reu-int
I can’t find this article in English, but the Japanese article says:
Rough translation for the gist of it:
And the monks were detained at a former governmental technical research center in the northern part of Rangoon and were vervally attacked/abused, but not physically attacked, according to the article.
Things are changing day to day, or even hour to hour. I still can’t find out exactly how many men and women have been detained.
And here’s another piece: a military officer has defected after refusing orders.
In English:
newsinfo.inquirer.net/breakingnews/world/view_article.php…
In Japanese:
headlines.yahoo.co.jp/hl?a=20071004-00000089-mai-int
# this is a copy of what I posted onto the Help Burma Now! group’s forum.
UPDATE:
Nagai’s cause of death is now officially confirmed in Tokyo. He was shot from the back, and the bullet gave an extensive damage to his liver, and he died from blood loss. (This is quite similar to what a Burmese doctor told to Mr Yamaji a few days ago.) How he was shot is yet to be confirmed. The Japanese police will conduct a full review of the footages of the moment, and examine his shirts and trousers.
In Japanese:
?????
headlines.yahoo.co.jp/hl?a=20071004-00000418-yom-int
UPDATE@5th October:
Nagai’s funeral is on Monday 8th October 2007 at Aoyama Saijo. See this post (in Japanese only) and/or a more updated post at "Protest the killing of Kenji Nagai" blog for more details.
The blog also hosts a petition to urge Burmese military government to give his camera back. See this post (in Japanese only) for more. More than 1,000 people have signed, including me.
Another petition in English and many other languages:
http://www.avaaz.org/en/stand_with_burma/w.php
I got to know of this petition on flickr (via somebody’s comment, or a post or two in related groups forum). Spread the word.
They sent this e-mail to me:
UPDATE@8 October 2007
Nagai’s funeral took place in Aoyama, Tokyo. I am now uploading pictures:
http://flickr.com/photos/nofrills/1514582153/
http://flickr.com/photos/nofrills/1514582165/
http://flickr.com/photos/nofrills/1514582175/
http://flickr.com/photos/nofrills/1514582183/
http://flickr.com/photos/nofrills/1514582189/
http://flickr.com/photos/nofrills/1514582195/
http://flickr.com/photos/nofrills/1515458466/
http://flickr.com/photos/nofrills/1515458468/
http://flickr.com/photos/nofrills/1515458482/
http://flickr.com/photos/nofrills/1515458486/
http://flickr.com/photos/nofrills/1515458504/
http://flickr.com/photos/nofrills/1514614051/
http://flickr.com/photos/nofrills/1514614083/
http://flickr.com/photos/nofrills/1514614105/
http://flickr.com/photos/nofrills/1514614109/
http://flickr.com/photos/nofrills/1514614115/
Sign an appeal to the UN Security Council to protect the people of Burma
free-burma.org
I would be really grateful if you could refrain from posting your images onto this thread because this webpage is intended to be strictly for updated news re: Kenji Nagai. There are plenty of pictures of mine on my flickr page where image posting is welcomed. Thank you for your understanding.
So, here’s another footage of the killing, and it perfectly captures how and when the camera was robbed of him:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LHh7kbsSxXs
I put English subs onto this news report/new footage:
jimaku.in/w/LHh7kbsSxXs/ArYWPW_ENCc
This footage was broadcast on the night of 8th October, the day Nagai’s funeral was held, on TV Asahi.
–
The English subs I put on:
There are some footage of the funeral on youtube.com. They were filmed by the mourners.
I mentioned these on my blog:
nofrills.seesaa.net/article/59866828.html#more
Click on the link, and scroll down to find some embedded youtube players. I put a brief English description (although the page itself is in Japanese) beside the youtube players. Hope this will help.
Kenji Nagai was cremated on 8th October, and his bones are now with his parents and siblings back in Ehime, his home town. I saw on TV Nagai’s mother telling reporters at the airport that she was very proud of her son. They held a farewell ceremony at a local temple. ???
Here’s a photo:
headlines.yahoo.co.jp/hl?a=20071014-00000007-maip-soci.vi…
The man standing in the centre of the picture is Toru Yamaji of the APF News.
And now, things are getting just too much. I can’t help but laugh.
First, in Japanese:
??????????????????????????
headlines.yahoo.co.jp/hl?a=20071013-00000115-yom-int
Not only Yomiuri, but also Asahi:
http://www.asahi.com/international/update/1013/TKY200710130222.html
And now, in English (an AP report):
http://www.usatoday.com/news/world/2007-10-14-burma-japanjournal...
And did I say that the bullet that killed him was already removed when his body came back to Japan? This, in effect, makes it impossible for a forensic pathologist to decide from what distance the soldier fired upon the journalist.
Anyway, it’s all too clear that the Burmese junta seem to be thinking they do something right when shooting unarmed civillians. The footage on 27 September showed the protesters along with the slain journaist, and they were just running away. They were not even throwing missiles, let alone shooting at the soldiers.
UPDATE@11:45 am, 16th October

The BBC News’s top page:
news.bbc.co.uk/
Japan adds to pressure on Burma
Last Updated: Tuesday, 16 October 2007, 01:43 GMT 02:43 UK
news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/asia-pacific/7046267.stm
But I’m not sure how much impact this will have on Burmese junta, because, as stated in the BBC article, the money would be used for higher education to build "good relationships" with Japan (that’s why they teach Japanese there).
And I’ve learned one veteran lawmaker questions about the shooting on Nagai (not answered yet, as of 16th October):
http://www.shugiin.go.jp/itdb_shitsumon.nsf/html/shitsumon/a1680...
http://www.shugiin.go.jp/itdb_shitsumon.nsf/html/shitsumon/a1680...
And it’s ????, if you know about Japanese politics!
here’s the BBC’s analysis (by Chirs Hogg) – I haven’t seen this sort of analysis in Japanese, but I believe there must be an article/column or to on the printed media. I think I’ve got to go to the library to check it out, but sadly enough, I haven’t got much spare time.
Japan’s balancing act on Burma
Last Updated: Tuesday, 16 October 2007, 18:53 GMT 19:53 UK
news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/asia-pacific/7047468.stm
The "eight other countries" must be: China, India, Thailand, the United Kingdom, the United States, the Netherlands, France (Total), and … one more country.
UPDATE (26 October 2007):
Mr Nagai’s friends and colleagues have been campaigning for the camera, which the Burmese junta say ‘was lost’. They set up a weblog (in Japanese) to protest against the killing and demand the camera be back. They have been collecting signatures since 2 October, which reached 10,000 this week.
Yesterday (25 October 2007) they handed the petition to the Burmese Embassy in Tokyo. Japan is filled with scandals at the moment – corruption at the defence agency/ministry, the bunkrupt of Nova, Kameda brothers’ boxing (or "fighting") etc – so I only saw a very short report on TV, but they have a detailed account about it on their weblog (in Japanese).
A rough translation:
UPDATE (26 October 2007):
Petition for Kenji Nagai’s camera in English (this is not my translation, I just copied and pasted from their website):
UPDATE (26 October 2007):
On Sunday, the NHK will be airing Nagai’s documentary film on AIDS orphans in Thailand.
10?28??????11?40????NHK??
NHK??????
???????????????75000???????? ????2001?
23.40, Sunday 28 October 2007, NHK Sogo (NHK One, like "BBC One"), in NHK Archives:
"AIDS Orphans are Mushrooming in Numbers: 75,000 Children in Thailand" (2001, ETV, NHK Educational Channel)
Post your comment